Date: 04 Jun 2010 7:14 am Title: Edward
Very Edward. And perfectly reasonable that Carlisle would not mention such a possibility to his family when he only wanted to promote compassion for humans. At least Edward was able to refrain and that is definitely a credit to Carlisle.
Date: 04 Jun 2010 6:49 am Title: Aro
Interesting. Before Carlisle's time. Would it have been discussed with him? Did it occur to him that Bella was Edward's singer? And Aro would have wanted to find out all he could before executing the vampire. Can't have everything Aro.